Morning All,
A week or two ago Pentaho
announced the purchase of Clear View from Lucidera and its been very interesting to see the range of opinion this has conjured up, which I find interesting because when it was announced that the Dashboard Designer was to be closed source, no one seemed to care, is it the right of every member of the Pentaho community to have enterprise level OLAP Analysis, or just those that cough up the money?
Seth Grimes has an interesting article asking whether Pentaho can really still call itself Commercial Open Source
James Dixon seems far from impressed with this blog post and has posted a retort pointing out that Pentaho already include the closed source Dashboard Designer and still offer far more open source functionality than the rivals.
Merv Adrian would like to point out that Pentaho is now technically 'Open Core'.
and lastly
Jos Van Dongen covered the release using words that I don't even know the meaning of(doesn't take much)! ;) But goes on to say that there's nothing really wrong with including it in EE but make sure the community edition doesn't suffer in the process.
What I have noticed over the last week is:
- I have yet to bump into anyone bitterly dissapointed that Clear View is EE only, although maybe thats because there isn't yet a demo available so people haven't seen it?
- I thought it would be a kick in the pants for PAT, far from it, its provided us with plenty of interest with website traffic currently up 28% and many more people enquiring as to when its been ready.
- Helpful suggestions and comments have increased, offers for help testing etc
So what does that say about the community, well I thought that JPivots flaws would see people desperate to buy EE and Clear View but that seems not the case. People seem far more interested in when we'll have a community version of PAT ready to replace JPivot. Now I know I speak for the community and not EE customers, and I have no knowledge of their thoughts and feelings behind Clear View.
My only real concern is that Pentaho will now be less inclined to include PAT within the server when we are stable as it would devalue the Clear View tool. I don't think I'm stepping out of line when I say that, it makes sense. But on the flip side I do think Pentaho need to include more stuff in their EE version because at the moment to companies like mine, support is not a big enough incentive to upgrade.
Anyway we shall see.
Thanks for all the support and we'll have a very unstable 0.5.0 out real soon for you all to break \o/
Cheers
Tom